Leap Months – The deepest secret of Judaism

Judaism –> Leap Months

The deepest secret of Judaism is the “sod ha’ibbur,” literally “the secret of the intercalation.”

“Intercalation” is a word that refers to the reconciliation of the solar and the lunar calendars. The need for such reconciliation is unique to Judaism.

More Articles by Rabbi Hillel Goldberg: What Did Abraham Hear? The solar calendar periodically needs a “leap day,” as it did this year, on Feb. 29. Seven times every nineteen years, the Jewish calendar needs a “leap month,” as it does this year (2000/5760). The leap month of the Hebrew calendar is always the month of Adar. Just scratching the surface of how all this is determined, one is amazed. The “sod ha’ibbur,” the secret of intercalation, leaves one speechless. Adar occurs twice this year, “Adar 1” and “Adar 2.” The periodic need to add a month to the Hebrew calendar is based on Deuteronomy 16:1, which requires that the festival of Passover always occur in the spring. Left to its own devices, a calendar based solely on the lunar cycle would move Passover away from spring. The Moslem calendar is strictly lunar; its holy month of Ramadan moves steadily backwards, eventually circling all the way around the solar calendar. In 1999, for example, Ramadan began on Dec. 9; in 2000, Ramadan begins on Nov. 27. Judaism needs an exception to its lunar cycle in order to ensure that Passover, each and every year, remains in the spring. The solution is to add a “leap month.” Every so often, as the lunar cycle pushes the month in which Passover falls, Nisan, back toward winter, an extra month is added. This pushes Passover forward again toward spring.

Spring, of course, is a season on the solar calendar. Therefore, the addition of a leap month is a reconciliation of the lunar and solar calendars. This is “intercalation.”

To move from intercalation in principle to intercalation in practice is very complicated. How often does one add a leap month? How many days should each one be? For that matter, how is it possible to standardize any month in the lunar cycle? This question stems from the fact that no lunar month corresponds to a solar month. Solar months are 30 or 31 days (and in one case, February, 28 or 29 days). A lunar month, however, is roughly 29.5 solar days. An odd number. This means that the lunar calendar requires more than a simple addition of one extra leap month every so often. The calculation must be more sophisticated. Any day added to the solar calendar is, by definition, in “whole solar days,” but the lunar time that the addition compensates for is not in whole solar days. To figure out exactly how often a leap month needs to be added to the lunar calendar, and exactly how many solar days it needs to be, a prerequisite is an accurate calculation of the lunar month. Here is where Judaism’s deepest secret begins to emerge. According to calculations derived from satellites orbiting the earth, the lunar month is exactly 29.530588 days long. When the Jewish calendar originated in antiquity, there were no satellites. Think, for a moment, what else there were none of—no computers (not even slide rules), no telescopes, no watches. Picture yourself looking up at the sky, lacking even the crudest instrument of measurement, and then figuring out the length of the lunar month. Before satellites, before telescopes, before virtually anything but the naked eye, the Jewish sages of antiquity calculated the lunar month at 29.53059 solar days. 29.53059 days = Sages’ measure 29.530588 = satellite measure The difference is 00.00002 = two one-millionths of a day. Other ancients also calculated the length of the lunar month, and also came close to the satellite measure, but not nearly so close as the ancient sages of Judaism. How did they know this? This is Level 1 of the “sod ha’ibbur,” of the “secret of intercalation.” Level 2 of the deep secret is the age-old philosphic issue of Divine omniscience and human freedom. If G-d knows everything, He knows in advance what any human being might “choose.” G-d’s advance knowledge is determinative. In other words, a person has no freedom of choice. But both G-d’s determinative omniscience and the human being’s freedom of choice are necessary. The sun represents steadiness, easy measurability, determinism. The Book of Ecclesiastes says of the sun, “there is nothing new under the sun” (1:9). The Book of Psalms says of the sun, “the sun knows [the regular timing] of its appearance” (100:14)—the sun is as it always was and always will be. Determinism. The moon’s appearance is not regular. It represents unpredictability, difficult measurability, freedom. The unit of the sun is the “year,” which in Hebrew also connotes “repetition”—determinism. The unit of the moon is the “month,” which in Hebrew also connotes “newness”—freedom. The deepest secret, the “sod ha’ibbur,” is the combination of determinism and freedom. The reconciliation of the solar and the lunar calendars. Divine guidance (“determinism”) together with human responsibility (“freedom”). Rabbi Aaron Lopiansky observes that humanity tends to the one asix or the other, to determinism or to freedom. Either: G-d is in control, human freedom is an illusion, life is a tragedy, moral effort is a waste (or, per Camus, meaningless): determinism. Or: Man is in control, Divine guidance is an illustion, life glorifies the successful, moral effort is a measure of preference: freedom. The Jewish perspective is not either/or—determinism or freedom—but both/and. The Jewish perspective is the “sod ha’ibbur,” the interrelationship of sun and moon. The “secret of intercalation” is the combination of G-d’s determinative and guiding hand and of man’s freedom of choice and responsibility. The Jewish people’s embrace of both is Level 2 of the deepest secret of Judaism. Sabbath literally rolls around every seventh day. The human has no role in its schedule. Sabbath represents G-d’s absolute guidance. Moed, or Jewish festival, is a consequence in antiquity of the human sighting of the “New Moon,” the first sliver of the renascent moon in the sky. Later, when the “secret of intercalation” was in danger of being lost, Hillel, a fourth-century sage, fixed the Jewish calendar for all time. The schedule of Jewish festivals is now based on that calendar (itself based on Level 1 of the secret of intercalation). In principle, however, the Jewish festivals stem from the human sighting of the moon each month. Moed, or Jewish festival, represents the human role in human freedom. Sabbath and festival together represent the interrelationship of the determinsim of G-d and the freedom of man. Sod ha’ibbur—the deepest secret of Judaism.

Rabbi Hillel Goldberg, Ph.D.([email protected]), is executive director of the Intermountain Jewish News ( Reprinted with permission of the Intermountain Jewish News